For the Crumbl cookie flavors this week we have Chocolate Cupcake, Pumpkin Roll, Pink Donut, Snickerdoodle, Maple Glaze, and Lemon Crinkle. There was also Cherry Cheesecake, but in the interest of being frugal, I stayed away from that one.
In first place we have the Pink Donut cookie. I rate this cookie a 10/10. This is a vanilla cookie with pink glaze and vanilla sprinkles. It was soft and the perfect amount of frosting and cookie. On the Crumbl cookie site this cookie has an average rating of 4.13 stars.
The cookie in second place is the Chocolate Cupcake. This cookie gets a 9/10. It is a vanilla sugar cookie with fudge frosting and chocolate sprinkles. It was soft and a good cookie, and maybe the only complaint was that it just had a lot of frosting — it’s chocolate, so that’s not necessarily a bad thing. This cookie has a rating of 4.17 stars.
In third place is the Pumpkin Roll. This was rated an 8.5/10. This is a soft pumpkin cookie with autumn spices and topped with a spiral vanilla cream cheese frosting. This cookie’s average star rating was 4.26.
The Lemon Crinkle cookie is in fourth place. This cookie is an 8 out of 10. It is a cake lemon cookie rolled in sugar crystals and powdered sugar. It has a star rating of 4.18 stars.
The cookie in fifth place is the Snickerdoodle cookie. This cookie gets an 7.5/10. It is a classic vanilla sugar cookie in a cinnamon sugar. It has an average star rating 4.43 stars.
In sixth place is the Maple Cookie and this cookie gets a 7/10. This cookie has brown sugar and is drizzled with maple glaze. This cookie was good but had a lot of butter. The average star rating for this is a 3.85.
Stay tuned for next week when Crumbl starts to unveil its Thanksgiving series of cookies and pies.
