Welcome back to another Crumbl cookie review after our break we are back with more cookies to review. This week is special because it’s Halloween weekend with special Halloween cookies. I will say that this week was very hard to rate because all these cookies were amazing this is probably one of our best lineups of cookies we’ve had in a while let’s get right into it.
Coming in first place is the Halloween Cake Batter Blondie This is a basic cake batter cookie filled with white chocolate and then to decorate the outside they have Halloween-inspired sprinkles. This is a warm delicious cookie it is overall very simple but delicious it tastes like a classic sugar cookie but with Gooey white chocolate to fill the inside I loved this cookie and I would get it again and again I rate this cookie 9/10
Coming in with a close second place is the Blue Monster featuring Chips Ahoy Cookie. This is a chilled cookie with a basic cookie base filled with semi-sweet chocolate chips and Chips Ahoy cookie pieces. Then to top the cookie we have a blue vanilla frosting with crumbles of Chips Ahoy and a small Chips Ahoy cookie on top. This is one of my favorite cookies I’ve had it many times and it is delicious the one downside is it is very sweet. So you can only have so much of this cookie at once even though you want to eat the entire cookie I highly recommend you try this cookie I rate this cookie 8.5/10
Coming in third place was the Pumpkin Cake. Although this is not a cookie it was so very good. This tasted straight out of fall and was exactly what you need right before Halloween a delicious dessert. This is a two-layered cake with pumpkin spice cake batter and vanilla bean frosting and then to top off the cake there are pieces of pumpkin cake. If you love pumpkin and cake this is exactly what you need it’s not too sweet because the cake balances it out but because it’s not a cookie we have to move it down in the rankings I highly recommend you also go try this because you won’t be able to stop eating it as soon as you try it. I rate this an 8.2/10
Coming in fourth place is Dirt Cake although this cookie does not look the most appealing it was very delicious and tasted exactly like the little dirt cake cups you used to get at birthday parties. This was a chocolate cookie base topped with fudge frosting and then cookie crumbles to top it off with a gummy worm. As much as I love chocolate this cookie was just too much I wish there would have been a little bit more crust to balance out the amount of chocolate but it was still very good. I rate this cookie a 7.3/10
Sadly coming in last place is Peanut Butter featuring Reese’s Pieces. Although this cookie was very good it was a basic peanut butter cookie packed with Reese’s Pieces and topped with Reese’s Pieces candies this cookie was just very basic. The taste was overwhelmed with peanut butter now if you’re a big fan of peanut butter this cookie is straight up your alley but this could use just nothing crazy or special and didn’t stand a chance against the crazy cookies this week. I rate this cookie a 6/10
See you next week for more Crumbl reviews !!
